MLB Memorabilia » Unsigned Trading Cards

free shipping
1988 Cape Cod Prospects Chatham A's Ballpark Card #23- Jeff Bagwell- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$174.99~~
$113.74
free shipping
1988 Cape Cod Prospects Chatham A's Ballpark Card #23- Jeff Bagwell- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$174.99~~
$113.74
free shipping
1988 Cape Cod Prospects Orleans Cardinals Ballpark Card #22- Frank Thomas- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shipping
1988 Cape Cod Prospects Orleans Cardinals Ballpark Card #22- Frank Thomas- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
Albert Pujols St. Louis Cardinals 2010 Topps All-Star Game Commemorative Patch Card #MCP150 CTB

~~$110.99~~
$72.14
Bill Johnson New York Yankees 1949 Bowman Baseball Card #129- PSA Graded 3 Very Good CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Billy Moran 1962 Topps Card #539 Los Angeles Angels Graded 6 PSA #27341917 KEN

~~$76.99~~
$50.04
free shipping
Billy Muffett St. Louis Cardinals 1958 Topps Baseball Card #143- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint CTB

~~$154.99~~
$100.74
Bob Rush Chicago Cubs 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #212- PSA Graded 6 Excellent- Mint CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
CC Sabathia Cleveland Indians 2001 Donruss Class Scrapbook Game Worn Jersey Card #SB-9- LTD 117/500 CTB

~~$115.99~~
$75.39
free shipping
Chipper Jones Durham Bulls 1992 Fleer ProCards Card #1108 BGS Beckett Graded 8.5 NM-MT+ w/ Set (28 Cards) CTB

~~$233.99~~
$152.09
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Chuck Hinton 1962 Topps Card #347 Washington Senators Graded 6 (MK) PSA #27341911 KEN

~~$76.99~~
$50.04
Danny Murtaugh Pittsburgh Pirates 1950 Bowman Baseball Card #203- PSA Graded 4 Very Good- Excellent CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
Dave Cole 1952 Bowman Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #132- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Boston Braves) CTB

~~$115.99~~
$75.39
Debs Garms Boston Bees 1939 Play Ball Baseball Card #72- PSA Graded 4.5 Very Good-Excellent+ CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Dick Littlefield 1952 Bowman Card #209 Detroit Tigers Graded 5 PSA #27107093 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Dick Littlefield 1952 Bowman Card #209 Detroit Tigers Graded 5 PSA #27107094 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
free shipping
Don Drysdale Los Angeles Dodgers 1964 Auravision Records 33 1/3 RPM Card #5 Gem Mint (Spindle unpopped) CTB

~~$198.99~~
$129.34
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Don Kolloway 1951 Bowman Card #105 Detroit Tigers Graded 4.5 PSA #27106942 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
free shipping
Duane Pillette St. Louis Cardinals 1953 Bowman B&W Baseball Card #59- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Ed Erautt 1952 Topps Card #171 Cincinnati Reds Graded 6 (MC) PSA #27107604 KEN

~~$128.99~~
$83.84
Everett Kell Philadelphia Athletics 1952 Bowman Baseball Card #242- PSA Graded 3 Very Good CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
free shipping
Frank Overmire Detroit Tigers 1949 Leaf Baseball Card #17- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (MC) CTB

~~$213.99~~
$139.09
free shipping
Frank Thomas 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #14- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$239.99~~
$155.99
free shipping
George Sisler 1950 Callahan Hall Of Fame Trading Card SSG Graded 84 NM 7 (St Louis Browns) CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
Greg Maddux Chicago Cubs 1987 Donruss Rated Rookie Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #36 CTB

~~$91.99~~
$59.79
free shipping
Hal McRae & Bill Henry 1968 Topps Rookie Stars Card (RC) #384- SGC Graded 84/7 NM CTB

~~$198.99~~
$129.34
Harmon Killebrew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Baseball Card #220- GMA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

~~$122.99~~
$79.94
free shipping
Heinie Mueller 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #96- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Philadelphia Phillies) CTB

~~$174.99~~
$113.74
free shipping
Howard Fox Philadelphia Phillies 1953 Bowman Color Baseball Trading Card #158- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (OC) CTB

~~$242.99~~
$157.94
Jack Morris Detroit Tigers 1978 Topps Rookie Pitchers Baseball Card #703- PSA Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
free shipping
Jeff Bagwell 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #4- Beckett Graded 8.5 Near Mint- Mint+ CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
Jeff Bagwell Houston Astros 2016 Topps Tribute Game Used Relic Card #TR-JB- LTD 143/196 CTB

~~$122.99~~
$79.94
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Joe Coleman 1951 Bowman Card #120 Philadelphia A's Graded 4.5 PSA #27106957 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Joe Koppe 1959 Topps Card #517 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 7 PSA #27341884 KEN

~~$117.99~~
$76.69
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Joe Lounett 1957 Topps Card #241 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 6 PSA #27341861 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
free shipping
Joe Tinker 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card #70- PGA Graded 9 Mint (Chicago Cubs) CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shipping
Joe/Joseph Heving Boston Red Sox 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #35- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
Johan Santana New York Mets 2010 Upper Deck Game Used Jersey Card #UDGJ-JS CTB

~~$115.99~~
$75.39
free shipping
John Smoltz Atlanta Braves 2015 Leaf Fantastic Fabrics Game Used Jersey Baseball Card #FF-15- LTD 2/6 CTB

~~$203.99~~
$132.59
Josh Hamilton 2011 Topps Factory Set Limited Edition Baseball Card #650- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (Texas Rangers) CTB

~~$104.99~~
$68.24
Justin Morneau Minnesota Twins 2005 Donruss Prime Patches Game Worn Jersey Card #NG-11- LTD 108/156 CTB

~~$104.99~~
$68.24
free shipping
Ken Griffey, Jr. California League 1988 All-Stars Minor League Card #26 BGS Beckett Graded 8.5 Near Mint-Mint+ w/ Set (50 Cards) CTB

~~$366.99~~
$238.54
Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners 1997 Upper Deck Gold Glove Award Commemorative 3.5x5 Inch Card- LTD to 5000 CTB

~~$91.99~~
$59.79
free shipping
Leo Kiely Boston Red Sox 1952 Topps Baseball Card #54 (black back)- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

~~$158.99~~
$103.34
Matt Harvey 2006-07 Team USA Baseball Rookie Baseball Card #45- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint CTB

~~$118.99~~
$77.34
free shipping
Matt Harvey 2010 Bowman Draft Prospects Rookie Baseball Card #BDPP84- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

~~$198.99~~
$129.34
Matt Harvey 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rookie Baseball Card #46- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (North Carolina) CTB

~~$104.99~~
$68.24
Matt Harvey 2011 Bowman Platinum Prospects Rookie Baseball Card #BPP66- PSA Graded Gem Mint 10 (New York Mets) CTB

~~$125.99~~
$81.89
free shipping
Matt Harvey 2012 Panini Prizm Rookie Baseball Card #179- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

~~$154.99~~
$100.74
Matt Harvey 2012 Topps Update Baseball Card #US23- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

~~$125.99~~
$81.89
free shipping
Mickey Cochran 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card Incorrect Name- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (Detroit Tigers) CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shipping
Miguel Sano Minnesota Twins 2018 Panini Immaculate Player Used Jersey Patch Card #IJ-MS- LTD 07/10 CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shipping
Mo Vaughn 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #16- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shipping
Mo Vaughn 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #16- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Moe Drabowsky 1957 Topps Rookie Card #84 Chicago Cubs Graded 4 PSA #27341860 KEN

~~$81.99~~
$53.29
free shipping
Morry Arnovich 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #97- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Philadelphia Phillies) CTB

~~$174.99~~
$113.74
free shipping
Napoleon Lajoie 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card #70- SGC Graded 84 Near Mint 7 CTB

~~$154.99~~
$100.74
Orlando Martinez Atlanta Braves 1968 Topps Baseball Card #578- PSA Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

~~$110.99~~
$72.14
free shipping
Phil Rizzuto New York Yankees 1949 Bowman Baseball Card #98 (no name on front) CTB

~~$189.99~~
$123.49
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Ray Monzant 1959 Topps Card #332 San Francisco Giants Graded 6 PSA #27341880 KEN

~~$76.99~~
$50.04
Ray Noble New York Giants 1952 Berk Ross Baseball Trading Card CTB

~~$94.99~~
$61.74
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Ray Semproch 1961 Topps Card #174 Washington Senators Graded 6 PSA #27341896 KEN

~~$76.99~~
$50.04
Robinson Cano Seattle Mariners 2016 Topps Tribute Game Used Relic Card #TD-RCA- LTD 23/99 CTB

~~$110.99~~
$72.14
Rod Carew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Baseball Card #363- GMA Graded 4.5 Very Good-Excellent+ CTB

~~$141.99~~
$92.29
free shipping
Rod Carew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Game Baseball Card (Ground Out)- Beckett Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
free shippingSAME DAY SHIPPING
Sandy Koufax 1962 Jello Card #109 Los Angeles Dodgers Authentic Hand Cut PSA #44863143 KEN

~~$348.99~~
$226.84
free shipping
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2018 Panini Immaculate Player Used Jersey Patch Card #SBM-SO- LTD 46/99 CTB

~~$179.99~~
$116.99
Ted Wilks St. Louis Cardinals 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #193- PSA Graded 4 Very Good- Excellent CTB

~~$132.99~~
$86.44
free shipping
Tom Ferrick New York Yankees 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #182- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

~~$154.99~~
$100.74
free shipping
Wally Westlake St. Louis Cardinals 1952 Topps Baseball Card #38 (black back)- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

~~$158.99~~
$103.34
free shippingSAME DAY SHIPPING
Wes Covington 1963 Topps Card #529 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 8 PSA #27341926 KEN

~~$182.99~~
$118.94
free shipping
Wilbert Robinson 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (Baltimore Orioles) CTB

~~$158.99~~
$103.34
free shipping
Aaron Judge (New York Yankees) 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Catching RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$748.99~~
$486.84
free shipping
Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Flair Baseball #340 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$748.99~~
$486.84
free shipping
Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Flair Baseball #340 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$995.99~~
$647.39
free shipping
Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Upper Deck Baseball #24 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$270.99~~
$176.14
free shipping
Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Upper Deck Baseball #24 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$366.99~~
$238.54
free shipping
Barry Bonds (Pittsburgh Pirates) 1986 Topps Traded Baseball #11T RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$2467.99~~
$1604.19
free shipping
Barry Bonds (Pittsburgh Pirates) 1986 Topps Traded Baseball #11T RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$2868.99~~
$1864.84
free shipping
Bill Ripken (Baltimore Orioles) 1989 Fleer Baseball #616 FF Error Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1698.99~~
$1104.34
free shipping
Bill Ripken (Baltimore Orioles) 1989 Fleer Baseball #616 FF Error Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$1851.99~~
$1203.79
free shipping
Bo Jackson (Kansas City Royals) 1987 Donruss Baseball #35 RC Rated Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$995.99~~
$647.39
free shipping
Bo Jackson (Kansas City Royals) 1987 Donruss Baseball #35 RC Rated Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$1054.99~~
$685.74
free shipping
Bo Jackson 1990 Score Baseball #697 B&W Bat On Shoulder Pads Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1711.99~~
$1112.79
free shipping
Bryce Harper (Washington Nationals) 2012 Topps Update Baseball #US183 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$865.99~~
$562.89
free shipping
Bryce Harper (Washington Nationals) 2012 Topps Update Baseball #US183 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$1129.99~~
$734.49
free shipping
Bryce Harper (Washington Nationals) 2012 Topps Update Baseball #US183 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (Silver Label) PS1

~~$995.99~~
$647.39
free shipping
Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) 1988 Score Traded Baseball #103T RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 (Silver Label) PS1

~~$350.99~~
$228.14
free shipping
Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) 1988 Score Traded Baseball #103T RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$379.99~~
$246.99
free shipping
Derek Jeter (New York Yankees) 1993 Topps Baseball #98 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$630.99~~
$410.14
free shipping
Derek Jeter (New York Yankees) 1993 Topps Gold Baseball #98 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$1783.99~~
$1159.59
$Eloy Jimenez (Chicago Cubs) 2014 Bowman DP Chrome Refractor Baseball #CTP33 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT$

free shipping
Eloy Jimenez (Chicago Cubs) 2014 Bowman DP Chrome Refractor Baseball #CTP33 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1026.99~~
$667.54
free shipping
Fernando Tatis Jr (San Diego Padres) 2019 Topps Series 2 Baseball #410 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1025.99~~
$666.89
free shipping
Frank Thomas (Chicago White Sox) 1990 Leaf Baseball #300 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1854.99~~
$1205.74
free shipping
Frank Thomas (Chicago White Sox) 1990 Leaf Baseball #300 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (Silver Label) PS1

~~$2136.99~~
$1389.04
free shipping
Greg Maddux (Chicago Cubs) 1987 Donruss Baseball #36 RC Rated Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1142.99~~
$742.94
free shipping
Jo Adell (Los Angeles Angels) 2017 Bowman Chrome Baseball #BDC95 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$497.99~~
$323.69
$Jo Adell (Los Angeles Angels) 2017 Bowman Chrome Refractor Baseball #BDC95 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT$

free shipping
Jo Adell (Los Angeles Angels) 2017 Bowman Chrome Refractor Baseball #BDC95 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$702.99~~
$456.94
free shipping
John Smoltz (Atlanta Braves) 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #17 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$410.99~~
$267.14
free shipping
Juan Soto (Washington Nationals) 2018 Topps Update Baseball #US300 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1289.99~~
$838.49
free shipping
Ken Griffey Jr (Seattle Mariners) 1989 Fleer Baseball #548 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$995.99~~
$647.39
free shipping
Ken Griffey Jr (Seattle Mariners) 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #1 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$1320.99~~
$858.64
free shipping
Ken Griffey Jr (Seattle Mariners) 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #1 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$1466.99~~
$953.54
free shipping
Kirby Puckett (Minnesota Twins) 1985 Topps Baseball #536 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$334.99~~
$217.74
free shipping
Kris Bryant (Chicago Cubs) 2015 Topps Close-Up Baseball #616 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$317.99~~
$206.69
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 4 (G) PS1

~~$6859.99~~
$4458.99
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 5 (A) PS1

~~$8035.99~~
$5223.39
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 6 (B) PS1

~~$9975.99~~
$6484.39
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 6 (D) PS1

~~$11915.99~~
$7745.39
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 OC (F) PS1

~~$29095.99~~
$18912.39
free shipping
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman (New York Mets) 1968 Topps Baseball #177 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 OC (Silver Label) (E) PS1

~~$44335.99~~
$28818.39
free shipping
Omar Vizquel (Seattle Mariners) 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #787 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$379.99~~
$246.99
free shipping
Pete Alonso (New York Mets) 2019 Topps Baseball #475 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$270.99~~
$176.14
free shipping
Randy Johnson (Montreal Expos) 1989 Upper Deck Baseball #25 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$924.99~~
$601.24
free shipping
Rickey Henderson (Oakland A's) 1980 Topps Baseball #482 RC Rookie Card - PSA 8 NM-MT (C) PS1

~~$4849.99~~
$3152.49
free shipping
Rickey Henderson (Oakland A's) 1980 Topps Baseball #482 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (A) PS1

~~$60961.99~~
$39625.29
free shipping
Rickey Henderson (Oakland A's) 1980 Topps Baseball #482 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (B) PS1

~~$38793.99~~
$25216.09
free shipping
Ronald Acuna (Atlanta Braves) 2018 Topps Update Baseball #US250 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$1025.99~~
$666.89
free shipping
Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) 1983 Topps Baseball #83 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$454.99~~
$295.74
free shipping
Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) 1983 Topps Baseball #83 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$497.99~~
$323.69
free shipping
Sammy Sosa (Chicago White Sox) 1990 Upper Deck Baseball #17 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$350.99~~
$228.14
free shipping
Sammy Sosa (Chicago White Sox) 1990 Upper Deck Baseball #17 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

~~$454.99~~
$295.74
free shipping
Sammy Sosa (Chicago White Sox) 1990 Upper Deck Baseball #17 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (Silver Label) PS1

~~$379.99~~
$246.99
free shipping
Vladimir Guerrero Jr (Toronto Blue Jays) 2019 Topps Baseball #NNO RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$748.99~~
$486.84
free shipping
Wade Boggs (Boston Red Sox) 1983 Topps Baseball #498 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

~~$630.99~~
$410.14
free shipping
Wander Franco (Tampa Bay Rays) 2019 Bowman Chrome Baseball #100 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

~~$995.99~~
$647.39
SAME DAY SHIPPING
Brooks Robinson 1963 Fleer Card #4 Baltimore Orioles KEN

~~$128.99~~
$83.84
free shippingSAME DAY SHIPPING
Derek Jeter 1999 Pacific Paramount Fielder's Choice Gold Glove Card #12 New York Yankees KEN

~~$154.99~~
$100.74
free shipping
Frank Thomas 1990 Leaf Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #300- Beckett Graded 9 Mint (Chicago White Sox) CTB

~~$317.99~~
$206.69
free shipping
Juan Gonzalez 1991 Topps Stadium Club Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #237- Beckett Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (Texas Rangers) CTB

~~$189.99~~
$123.49
free shippingSAME DAY SHIPPING
Ted Tappe 1956-59 Seattle Rainiers Popcorn 8x10 Premium Card KEN

~~$159.99~~
$103.99

MLB Memorabilia » Unsigned Trading Cards

1988 Cape Cod Prospects Chatham A's Ballpark Card #23- Jeff Bagwell- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

1988 Cape Cod Prospects Chatham A's Ballpark Card #23- Jeff Bagwell- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

1988 Cape Cod Prospects Orleans Cardinals Ballpark Card #22- Frank Thomas- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

1988 Cape Cod Prospects Orleans Cardinals Ballpark Card #22- Frank Thomas- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

Albert Pujols St. Louis Cardinals 2010 Topps All-Star Game Commemorative Patch Card #MCP150 CTB

Bill Johnson New York Yankees 1949 Bowman Baseball Card #129- PSA Graded 3 Very Good CTB

Billy Moran 1962 Topps Card #539 Los Angeles Angels Graded 6 PSA #27341917 KEN

Billy Muffett St. Louis Cardinals 1958 Topps Baseball Card #143- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint CTB

Bob Rush Chicago Cubs 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #212- PSA Graded 6 Excellent- Mint CTB

CC Sabathia Cleveland Indians 2001 Donruss Class Scrapbook Game Worn Jersey Card #SB-9- LTD 117/500 CTB

Chipper Jones Durham Bulls 1992 Fleer ProCards Card #1108 BGS Beckett Graded 8.5 NM-MT+ w/ Set (28 Cards) CTB

Chuck Hinton 1962 Topps Card #347 Washington Senators Graded 6 (MK) PSA #27341911 KEN

Danny Murtaugh Pittsburgh Pirates 1950 Bowman Baseball Card #203- PSA Graded 4 Very Good- Excellent CTB

Dave Cole 1952 Bowman Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #132- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Boston Braves) CTB

Debs Garms Boston Bees 1939 Play Ball Baseball Card #72- PSA Graded 4.5 Very Good-Excellent+ CTB

Dick Littlefield 1952 Bowman Card #209 Detroit Tigers Graded 5 PSA #27107093 KEN

Dick Littlefield 1952 Bowman Card #209 Detroit Tigers Graded 5 PSA #27107094 KEN

Don Drysdale Los Angeles Dodgers 1964 Auravision Records 33 1/3 RPM Card #5 Gem Mint (Spindle unpopped) CTB

Don Kolloway 1951 Bowman Card #105 Detroit Tigers Graded 4.5 PSA #27106942 KEN

Duane Pillette St. Louis Cardinals 1953 Bowman B&W Baseball Card #59- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

Ed Erautt 1952 Topps Card #171 Cincinnati Reds Graded 6 (MC) PSA #27107604 KEN

Everett Kell Philadelphia Athletics 1952 Bowman Baseball Card #242- PSA Graded 3 Very Good CTB

Frank Overmire Detroit Tigers 1949 Leaf Baseball Card #17- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (MC) CTB

Frank Thomas 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #14- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

George Sisler 1950 Callahan Hall Of Fame Trading Card SSG Graded 84 NM 7 (St Louis Browns) CTB

Greg Maddux Chicago Cubs 1987 Donruss Rated Rookie Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #36 CTB

Hal McRae & Bill Henry 1968 Topps Rookie Stars Card (RC) #384- SGC Graded 84/7 NM CTB

Harmon Killebrew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Baseball Card #220- GMA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

Heinie Mueller 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #96- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Philadelphia Phillies) CTB

Howard Fox Philadelphia Phillies 1953 Bowman Color Baseball Trading Card #158- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (OC) CTB

Jack Morris Detroit Tigers 1978 Topps Rookie Pitchers Baseball Card #703- PSA Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

Jeff Bagwell 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #4- Beckett Graded 8.5 Near Mint- Mint+ CTB

Jeff Bagwell Houston Astros 2016 Topps Tribute Game Used Relic Card #TR-JB- LTD 143/196 CTB

Joe Coleman 1951 Bowman Card #120 Philadelphia A's Graded 4.5 PSA #27106957 KEN

Joe Koppe 1959 Topps Card #517 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 7 PSA #27341884 KEN

Joe Lounett 1957 Topps Card #241 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 6 PSA #27341861 KEN

Joe Tinker 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card #70- PGA Graded 9 Mint (Chicago Cubs) CTB

Joe/Joseph Heving Boston Red Sox 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #35- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

Johan Santana New York Mets 2010 Upper Deck Game Used Jersey Card #UDGJ-JS CTB

John Smoltz Atlanta Braves 2015 Leaf Fantastic Fabrics Game Used Jersey Baseball Card #FF-15- LTD 2/6 CTB

Josh Hamilton 2011 Topps Factory Set Limited Edition Baseball Card #650- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (Texas Rangers) CTB

Justin Morneau Minnesota Twins 2005 Donruss Prime Patches Game Worn Jersey Card #NG-11- LTD 108/156 CTB

Ken Griffey, Jr. California League 1988 All-Stars Minor League Card #26 BGS Beckett Graded 8.5 Near Mint-Mint+ w/ Set (50 Cards) CTB

Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners 1997 Upper Deck Gold Glove Award Commemorative 3.5x5 Inch Card- LTD to 5000 CTB

Leo Kiely Boston Red Sox 1952 Topps Baseball Card #54 (black back)- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

Matt Harvey 2006-07 Team USA Baseball Rookie Baseball Card #45- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint CTB

Matt Harvey 2010 Bowman Draft Prospects Rookie Baseball Card #BDPP84- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

Matt Harvey 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rookie Baseball Card #46- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (North Carolina) CTB

Matt Harvey 2011 Bowman Platinum Prospects Rookie Baseball Card #BPP66- PSA Graded Gem Mint 10 (New York Mets) CTB

Matt Harvey 2012 Panini Prizm Rookie Baseball Card #179- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

Matt Harvey 2012 Topps Update Baseball Card #US23- BGS Graded 9.5 Gem Mint (New York Mets) CTB

Mickey Cochran 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card Incorrect Name- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (Detroit Tigers) CTB

Miguel Sano Minnesota Twins 2018 Panini Immaculate Player Used Jersey Patch Card #IJ-MS- LTD 07/10 CTB

Mo Vaughn 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #16- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

Mo Vaughn 1988 Cape Cod Prospects Ballpark Baseball Card #16- Beckett Graded 9 Mint CTB

Moe Drabowsky 1957 Topps Rookie Card #84 Chicago Cubs Graded 4 PSA #27341860 KEN

Morry Arnovich 1940 Play Ball Baseball Card #97- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent (Philadelphia Phillies) CTB

Napoleon Lajoie 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card #70- SGC Graded 84 Near Mint 7 CTB

Orlando Martinez Atlanta Braves 1968 Topps Baseball Card #578- PSA Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

Phil Rizzuto New York Yankees 1949 Bowman Baseball Card #98 (no name on front) CTB

Ray Monzant 1959 Topps Card #332 San Francisco Giants Graded 6 PSA #27341880 KEN

Ray Noble New York Giants 1952 Berk Ross Baseball Trading Card CTB

Ray Semproch 1961 Topps Card #174 Washington Senators Graded 6 PSA #27341896 KEN

Robinson Cano Seattle Mariners 2016 Topps Tribute Game Used Relic Card #TD-RCA- LTD 23/99 CTB

Rod Carew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Baseball Card #363- GMA Graded 4.5 Very Good-Excellent+ CTB

Rod Carew Minnesota Twins 1968 Topps Game Baseball Card (Ground Out)- Beckett Graded 6 Excellent-Mint CTB

Sandy Koufax 1962 Jello Card #109 Los Angeles Dodgers Authentic Hand Cut PSA #44863143 KEN

Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2018 Panini Immaculate Player Used Jersey Patch Card #SBM-SO- LTD 46/99 CTB

Ted Wilks St. Louis Cardinals 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #193- PSA Graded 4 Very Good- Excellent CTB

Tom Ferrick New York Yankees 1951 Bowman Baseball Card #182- PSA Graded 5 Excellent CTB

Wally Westlake St. Louis Cardinals 1952 Topps Baseball Card #38 (black back)- PSA Graded 4 Very Good-Excellent CTB

Wes Covington 1963 Topps Card #529 Philadelphia Phillies Graded 8 PSA #27341926 KEN

Wilbert Robinson 1950 Callahan HOF Trading Card- PSA Graded 7 Near Mint (Baltimore Orioles) CTB

Aaron Judge (New York Yankees) 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Catching RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Flair Baseball #340 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1

Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Flair Baseball #340 RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT (New Label) PS1

Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Upper Deck Baseball #24 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT PS1

Alex Rodriguez (Seattle Mariners) 1994 Upper Deck Baseball #24 RC Rookie Card - PSA 9 MINT (New Label) PS1

Barry Bonds (Pittsburgh Pirates) 1986 Topps Traded Baseball #11T RC Rookie Card - PSA 10 GEM MINT PS1